Unsealed court filings reveal Microsoft executive calling AI scraping theft
Newly unsealed court filings reveal that a Microsoft executive privately characterized OpenAI's data harvesting as "theft" and "the largest theft of labor in human history." The records indicate that both companies scraped paywalled content from The New York Times to build datasets, despite internal warnings that doing so would financially undermine publishers. Claims are as reported; this summary makes no determination about accuracy or significance.
- First detected
- Sep 17, 2026
- Last updated
- Sep 18, 2026
High confidence
Independently reported by multiple publishers.
Corroborated
Corroborated across 2 independent sources
What does this mean?
Corroboration measures how many genuinely independent sources support the event. Confidence measures how reliable the available evidence appears.
No material changes recently.
Stable
No recent reporting has materially changed the known facts.
Follow this development to see meaningful updates as new evidence emerges.
Save keeps this for later. Follow tracks meaningful changes as new evidence emerges — it shapes your Following Feed, alerts, and digest eligibility, and doesn't promise an instant notification.
Why it matters
The internal acknowledgments could undermine fair use defenses in active copyright litigation, potentially increasing legal exposure and financial liability for AI vendors. The revelation reinforces legal pressure on foundational model developers to transition toward formal commercial data licensing agreements rather than uncompensated scraping.
Coverage
Independent reporting2 sources
Primary/vendor sources vs independent reporting
Primary / vendor source: information published directly by the company, organization, government body or project involved. Useful as a primary source, but not independent confirmation.
Independent reporting: reporting or analysis from a source independent of the organization making the underlying claim.
Timeline
Oct 19, 2026
Development status changed
Developing → Stable — new reporting is no longer substantially changing the known facts
Sep 18, 2026
Corroboration updated
The set of supporting sources changed.
Development status changed
New → Developing — new reporting is still materially changing this development
New reporting added
AI training built on fair use looks shaky when the companies' own people call it "astonishing theft"The DecoderIndependent reporting
Sep 17, 2026
Development detected
New reporting added
Microsoft exec called AI scraping ‘the largest theft of labor in human history,’ new unredacted filings revealTechCrunchIndependent reporting
Related Intelligence
- ReportAlso involving ChatGPT
OpenAI's upcoming chat-and-work merger in ChatGPT signals the end of all-you-can-prompt pricing
OpenAI plans to merge Chat and Work modes into a unified interface starting in December, according to The Decoder. Under the change, Plus, Pro, and Business subscriptions will share a token-based quota across ChatGPT and Codex, where complex models consume more allocation while simple instant chats remain uncounted.
The Decoder - ReportAlso involving ChatGPT
OpenAI slashes funding target by $10bn as tech anxieties mount
Financial Times reports that OpenAI has reduced its fundraising target by $10 billion, now seeking approximately $20 billion at a $1.25 trillion valuation amid growing broader tech market anxieties.
Financial Times (AI) - ReportAlso involving ChatGPT
OpenAI is steering ChatGPT users toward more paid usage
OpenAI has implemented limits on the number of paid ChatGPT accounts permitted per device and payment card. Under the new policy, users who reach the limit cannot initiate new subscriptions or access affected accounts on that device, with logging out failing to release the assigned slot. The measure restricts users attempting to bypass usage limits through multiple lower-tier subscriptions.
The Decoder - ReportAlso involving Microsoft
The biggest names in AI are backing a new way to opt out of scraping
OpenAI, Google, Microsoft, and Anthropic have agreed to adopt a unified standard allowing web publishers to opt out of AI scraping. The mechanism relies on a shared policy token signal, enabling website operators to apply AI training data preferences across multiple AI vendors simultaneously rather than managing individual crawler exclusion rules.
The Verge